11/01/2022 - Turning up the heat on worldwide gas prices
Pressures on supply range from Russian manoeuvres to a fierce global bidding war. The recent turmoil in global gas markets has left even seasoned observers reeling.
“During the past couple of weeks, the gas market has witnessed an extreme rollercoaster ride,” Ole Hansen, of Saxo Bank, said.
“Before Christmas, very cold weather across Europe and the UK helped to send EU benchmark gas to a level that was ten times higher than the long-term average. This was followed by a 65 per cent price collapse in response to news that multiple liquefied natural gas ships had changed course from Asia and South America to Europe in order to sell their gas at the highest price on the planet.”
With a sudden spell of milder weather over the festive period also helping to ease supply crunch concerns, Britain starts the new year with prices down from those all-time highs of more than 450p a therm reached before Christmas, but still above 200p. “These are incredibly high prices,” Nathan Piper, of Investec, said. “They’re still four times the ten-year average.”
Experts are warning that the roller-coaster ride may not be over yet. There are two key variables in the short term, according to Biraj Borkhataria, of RBC Capital Markets. “One is weather: if we have a cold snap, Europe is highly exposed to a spike in prices. The second is geopolitical factors: at the start of this year, Russian supply into Europe took another leg down. That can be quite material, given Russia supplies 25 per cent to 30 per cent of European gas.”
With Russia amassing troops near the Ukrainian border and America threatening sanctions, the potential fallout for energy markets is under close scrutiny. RBC analysts note that the US government is already contingency planning for “a possible Russian invasion in the coming weeks and for Russia weaponising energy exports in response to western sanctions. “We think that Moscow could take a page from its 2009 playbook and cut gas supplies into Europe from already lower levels in response to stepped-up western financial sanctions,” they warned in a note last week. Borkhataria believes that “in an invasion scenario, all bets are off with regards to gas prices”.
Of course, it’s hard to predict how Moscow would react. Piper argues that “Russia supplied gas to Germany throughout the Cold War — so they have been through some very tight geopolitical events and maintained supply to Europe”. Yet even if a worst-case scenario with Russia is averted, analysts appear increasingly united in their view that high gas prices are here to stay for the next few years.
Gas markets are increasingly global: neither Asia nor Europe is able to meet its gas needs domestically, so are reliant on imports of LNG, with cargoes sailing to the highest bidders. Piper said last year’s rally began with a cold snap in Asia last winter that “drew a lot of gas, a lot of LNG resources to Asia very quickly, unexpectedly”. That winter in Europe also lasted longer than usual, depleting storage supplies.
“That was then combined with the underperformance by wind in Europe and hydro in Asia as well, so there was increased gas demand for power,” he said. “All the way through the summer of last year, gas prices were too high to incentivise putting gas into storage.”
The result was that Europe entered this winter with storage at record lows. At the same time, “we’ve seen China outstrip Japan as the biggest importer of LNG, particularly because they want to make sure they’ve got blue skies for the Winter Olympics and burn gas rather than coal”, according to Piper.
As well as heightened demand, there have been disruptions to supply. LNG facilities in countries including Nigeria, Trinidad and Tobago and Equatorial Guinea are producing less than expected and Shell’s huge Prelude floating LNG plant off Australia, which alone produces about 1 per cent of global LNG supplies, has suffered repeated problems and is out of action. North Sea production has fallen, too, in part because of pandemic-induced delays to maintenance.
The tightness in supply and demand is not expected to ease in the near future. “Demand is likely to continue to increase as people shut down coal-fired power and nuclear, so the only thing you’ve got to back up intermittent renewables is gas,” Piper said. There was likely to be “incremental new supply, but it’s not like there’s a new flood of gas coming into the market”.
Russia’s new Nord Stream 2 pipeline, which could bolster supplies to Europe, is not expected to start up until the summer at the earliest — politics permitting.
Investec predicts that prices will remain at more than 100p a therm throughout 2022, which is in line with an industry-compiled consensus of forecasts — but with “risk to the upside”: forward gas markets are already pricing gas well above that level.
“You want cheap gas in the summer to refill European storage,” Piper said. “That’s probably not going to happen this year because the gas price is still very high, so you’re going to have that same set-up going into next winter.” He predicts “a prolonged period of high gas prices for at least 18 months”, with prices likely to ease significantly only in the summer of 2023 if renewables deliver and storage can be replenished, putting Europe in a better position for the winter of 2023-24.
Borkhataria also believes that gas prices will remain “elevated for a few years because of low storage and Europe structurally reducing its baseload power capabilities from nuclear and coal and adding more and more intermittent renewables.
“For the periods where the wind doesn’t blow or the sun doesn’t shine, you’re still going to need gas, and with declining production the region is highly reliant on imports, leaving it exposed to events outside Europe. There is enough gas resource globally, but it requires capital to be developed. If you don’t invest enough and try to wean yourself off fossil fuels without renewables hitting critical mass, we end up [with] problems like this. You can’t turn around the entire global energy system overnight.”
Piper echoed that warning: “The inconvenient truth is that we want to perform an energy transition and a lot of the focus has been on cutting supply. If you don’t invest in supply and your demand keeps going up because you’re shutting coal-fired and nuclear power stations, this is the unintended consequence.”
Source: Times